Does embroidery ruin a waterproof jacket?
Why the stitches leak, the press and iron settings for two seal films in one table, which setting suits metallic thread, and when a transfer is the better choice than embroidery.
Quick answer
Not if you seal it. Each stitch punches through the jacket's waterproof coating or membrane, so fuse a polyurethane seal film over the back of the stitching. Madeira Easy Water Seal: 120°C, 3 bar, 5 to 8 seconds on a press. Cover-A-Stitch Thermoseal: 130 to 150°C, medium pressure, 10 to 15 seconds. Overlap the stitching by 2 cm and wait 48 hours before washing.
On this page
Key takeaways
- Every stitch is a needle hole through the layer that keeps the rain out. Left open, the logo leaks.
- Seal the back with a heat-applied polyurethane film made for the job, such as Madeira Easy Water Seal or Cover-A-Stitch Thermoseal.
- Easy Water Seal: 120°C, 3 bar, 5 to 8 seconds on a press. Thermoseal: 130 to 150°C, medium pressure, 10 to 15 seconds.
- Cut the film 2 cm past the stitching, put the glossy adhesive side down, and wait 48 hours before you wash it.
- A lighter design and a size 60 or 70 needle leave fewer and smaller holes to seal.
Embroidery does not ruin a waterproof jacket, but it does put holes in it, and those holes leak until you seal them. A waterproof jacket keeps rain out with a layer behind the outer fabric. That layer is either a coating, a thin skin of polyurethane (PU) or vinyl spread on the back of the cloth, or a membrane, a separate thin film bonded inside it. The outer fabric alone does not stop the rain. The needle goes straight through that layer once for every stitch. Strauss, a workwear maker, puts it plainly: with embroidery, "needles must perforate the fabric, which can damage the functional membrane."
The fix is a seal film: a thin sheet of polyurethane with heat-activated glue on one side. You press it over the back of the finished stitching, and it covers every hole at once. AllStitch and Sulky both say that once it is on, water "will not penetrate the fabric through the tiny embroidery needle punctures." Madeira's Easy Water Seal has two layers, one of glue and one barrier, and Madeira sells it to "permanently seal embroidery on waterproof textiles".
Seal film settings by product
Every figure below is the maker's own. Where a maker gives no figure, the cell says so.
| Product | Heat press | Household iron | Cut size | Adhesive side | Before washing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Madeira Easy Water Seal (100% polyurethane, 120 g/m²) | 120°C (248°F), 3 bar, about 5 to 8 s | 2 to 3 dots by fabric, no steam. Bond lightly first, then press as hard as you can, at least 30 s | At least 2 cm overlap around the embroidery | Shiny side to the back of the embroidery | Full adhesion after 48 hours |
| Cover-A-Stitch Thermoseal (AllStitch) | 130 to 150°C (266 to 300°F), medium pressure, 10 to 15 s | Not given: AllStitch says to seal with a heat press | Slightly larger than the design | Adhesive side down. It faces out on the roll and looks slightly glossy | Let it set 48 hours before any washing test |
Madeira says a hot air sealer works too, and that a heat press is the method to choose whenever the fabric can take it. Sulky sells Stitch 'n Seal for the same job: it "seals the back of waterproof fabric after machine embroidery". Its product page gives no temperature or time, so follow the instructions that come with it.
Which setting to use, and why not three dots
The two films do not share one heat, and the thread on the front has its own limit. Our thread wash and iron temperatures page reads those limits from Madeira's data sheets. Polyester and rayon are rated to two dots on an iron, at most 160°C. Metallic thread is rated to one dot, at most 120°C.
Set the films against those limits and the choice is clear:
- On a press, either film is safe for polyester and rayon. Easy Water Seal runs at 120°C, Thermoseal at 130 to 150°C. Both sit under 160°C.
- With metallic thread, use Easy Water Seal on a press. Its 120°C is the one setting here that stays at the metallic limit. Thermoseal starts above it.
- On an iron, use two dots, not three. Madeira allows 2 to 3 dots for Easy Water Seal. Three dots runs up to 210°C. That is past the two-dot rating on Madeira's own Polyneon and Classic thread sheets.
The jacket fabric has a limit too, and no table can give it. Madeira says to test heat and adhesion before production, because fabrics and finishes vary so widely. It also says to iron or press a coated or specially finished fabric once before the film goes on.
Embroider and seal, or print instead?
Two answers circulate. Strauss does not recommend embroidery on functional jackets at all. It says the needles can damage the membrane, so the jacket can lose its waterproofing, windproofing and breathability. It recommends transfer printing instead, a film applied to the outer layer "without perforating the membrane". The film makers say the opposite: seal the back and the wearer stays dry. AllStitch names rain gear, outdoor jackets and work clothes for road building and gardening.
Both are right about the holes. Where they part is the jacket. Madeira designed Easy Water Seal for "light to medium weight vinyl or polyurethane coated fabrics, ideal for raincoats and waterproof jackets." That is coated rainwear and workwear, and on those, embroider and seal. A breathable membrane shell is the jacket Strauss is warning about. A film can cover the holes, but no maker here claims the sealed patch still breathes. So on a costly membrane shell you cannot test, choose a transfer or an embroidered patch pressed on, as in heat press patches. Neither puts a needle through it.
Make fewer, smaller holes before you seal
Every stitch is one needle hole, so the design decides how many holes there are. A default fill runs about 425 stitches per square inch, plus 10 to 20 percent for underlay, as stitches per square inch works out. Outlines, lettering and open designs make far fewer holes than solid fills. Madeira's advice for high-tech fabrics points the same way: lower the stitch density at corners and small curves, and keep underlay light.
The needle decides how big each hole is. A needle's metric size is its blade width in hundredths of a millimeter, so a 75 is 0.75 mm across and a 60 is 0.60 mm, says SCHMETZ. Madeira calls needle sizes 60 or 70 "perfectly suited for functional fabrics", with finer thread such as 60 weight. It also prefers a light ballpoint here, because it pushes fibers aside, while a regular sharp point "might destroy fibres". Madeira's stated reason is puckering. Fewer and smaller holes come with it. Match the thread to the needle as embroidery needles sets out: 60 weight thread runs on a 65/9 or 70/10. The same two rules keep feathers in a down jacket, as puffer jacket and down vest embroidery explains.
Hooping matters too. Our adhesives and fusibles guide keeps fusible stabilizers off some rain and technical shells. That rule is about fusing a backing before you stitch, and it still holds. A seal film is a different product: it is made for coated fabric and goes on after the stitching, at a stated heat. Hoop the shell with a sticky stabilizer, tape or basting, and do not stretch it in the hoop, as Madeira also advises. AllStitch says to remove the stabilizer before the film goes on, so the film bonds to the fabric. A backing that comes away cleanly makes that easy; cutaway vs tearaway covers the choice.
Worked example: a left chest logo on a coated rain jacket
Take a PU-coated rain jacket and a logo 3.5 by 2 inches (89 by 51 mm), the usual size from left chest placement. Suppose half of it is solid fill and the rest is lettering.
- Count the holes. The logo covers 7 square inches, so the fill is 3.5. At about 425 stitches per square inch, that is roughly 1,500 holes. Underlay adds 10 to 20 percent, so about 1,650 to 1,800, before any lettering. Turn the fill into an outline and most of those holes go away.
- Pick the needle. A 70/10 is 0.70 mm across, inside Madeira's 60 or 70 range for functional fabric.
- Test the film first. Before stitching, press a small piece of film onto the inside of the jacket where it will not show. If it sticks, go ahead, as AllStitch directs.
- Cut the film. With 2 cm of overlap on every side, the piece is 89 + 40 by 51 + 40 mm. That is about 13 by 9 cm (5 by 3.5 inches).
- Press it. Pre-press the coated fabric once. Lay the film shiny side down on the back of the stitching. Press at 120°C and 3 bar for 5 to 8 seconds. If the logo has metallic thread, this is still the right setting, since it stays at the one-dot limit.
- Wait. Leave it 48 hours before you wash the jacket or test it with water. That is when Madeira says the glue reaches full strength.
Seal it, step by step
- Test before you stitch. If a small piece of film will not stick to the back of the fabric, do not embroider that jacket.
- Stitch light. Use a 60 or 70 needle, with the shell hooped without a fusible and without stretching.
- Clear the back. Remove the stabilizer, trim the threads, and pre-press coated fabric once.
- Cut and place the film. Make it at least 2 cm larger than the stitching on every side, and lay it glossy glue side down.
- Press at your film's setting. With an iron, use two dots and no steam: set it down lightly, then press hard for 30 seconds or more.
- Leave it 48 hours before washing or a water test.
What this does not cover
These settings come from two film makers, written for coated fabrics, and they stop there. Neither gives a setting for any named membrane, and no source here says a sealed patch still breathes, so a membrane shell is a test-first job or a transfer job. The jacket's fabric limit is not in the table: if the test piece will not stick, or the fabric shines or marks at the setting, do not stitch that jacket. Madeira calls its care advice "for reference only" on delicate waterproof fabric and says to test other cleaning and drying methods first. For a film not listed here, use its maker's figure; do not borrow Thermoseal's 150°C. And a seal film is not a comfort cover. If the back needs to feel soft as well, see cover backing for itchy stitches.
Frequently asked questions
Does embroidery make a rain jacket leak?
It can. Every stitch is a needle hole through the coating or membrane that keeps the rain out. A heat-applied seal film over the back of the stitching covers those holes; AllStitch and Sulky say water then will not get through the needle punctures.
Can I iron on Madeira Easy Water Seal instead of using a press?
Yes. Madeira gives 2 to 3 dots with no steam, a light first bond and then firm pressure for at least 30 seconds. Use two dots: three dots runs past the limit for polyester and rayon thread. Madeira prefers a heat press whenever the fabric allows it.
How long before I can wash a jacket after sealing the embroidery?
48 hours. Madeira says Easy Water Seal reaches full adhesive force after 48 hours, and AllStitch says to let Thermoseal set 48 hours before any washing test.
What needle should I use on a waterproof jacket?
Madeira recommends sizes 60 or 70 for functional fabrics, with finer thread and a light ballpoint. A smaller needle leaves a smaller hole: the size number is the blade width in hundredths of a millimeter.
Is printing better than embroidery on a waterproof jacket?
On a breathable membrane shell, often yes. Strauss recommends transfer printing for functional jackets because it does not perforate the membrane. On coated rainwear and workwear, embroidery sealed with a film made for coated fabric is what the seal makers design for.
Sources and further reading
- Madeira: Easy Water Seal technical data sheet (PDF) 100% PU, 120 g/m², two layers; for light to medium vinyl or PU coated fabrics; press 120°C, 3 bar, 5 to 8 s; iron 2 to 3 dots, no steam, at least 30 s; 2 cm overlap; shiny side down; full adhesion after 48 hours
- AllStitch: Cover-A-Stitch Thermoseal Press 130 to 150°C (266 to 300°F), medium pressure, 10 to 15 s; remove stabilizer first; glossy adhesive side down; 48 hours before washing tests; test before embroidering
- Sulky: Stitch 'n Seal Seals the back of waterproof fabric after machine embroidery (purpose only; no settings published on the page)
- Strauss: For which products is embroidery not recommended? Needles perforate the functional membrane; transfer printing recommended for functional jackets
- Madeira: Challenges embroidering high-tech fabrics Needle sizes 60 or 70, light ballpoint, finer thread, lighter underlay and density for functional fabrics
- SCHMETZ: Needle size designations NM size is the blade diameter in hundredths of a millimeter
Found something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we will fix it.