Can you embroider FR clothing, and does the logo need FR thread?

Yes, and for a normal logo, no. The two US standards for flame resistant workwear exempt embroidery thread and cap non-FR emblems by size. Here are the clauses, the FR threads that exist when you go past the cap, and a left chest logo worked through.

Updated 9 min read Reviewed against our editorial standards

Quick answer

Yes, you can embroider FR clothing, and a logo of normal size does not need FR thread. NFPA 2112 excludes embroidery from its thread rule, and ASTM F1506's thread rule covers construction thread only. Both advise that non-FR emblems stay under 16 sq in each and 40 sq in in total, and NFPA adds a maximum of five. Past that, use FR thread, FR bobbin thread and FR backing.

On this page
  1. Key takeaways
  2. What the standards say about embroidery
  3. Why "you must use FR thread" keeps circulating
  4. When you use FR thread, use the whole kit
  5. FR embroidery threads by maker
  6. Worked example: a 4 x 4 in left chest logo
  7. What this does not cover

Key takeaways

  • You can embroider FR clothing. Neither NFPA 2112 nor ASTM F1506 requires FR thread for a logo or a name.
  • Both advise a size cap for emblems that are not flame resistant: 16 sq in (103 cm²) each and 40 sq in (258 cm²) in total. NFPA 2112 adds a maximum of five.
  • A 4 x 4 in left chest logo is 16 sq in. That is at the cap, not over it.
  • Past the cap, use FR thread such as Madeira Fire Fighter, Amann N-tech CS or Coats Pyrostar. Pair it with an FR bobbin thread and an FR backing.
  • The garment maker and the employer's hazard assessment have the last word.

Yes, you can embroider flame resistant clothing, and a normal logo does not need FR thread. NFPA 2112 applies its thread rule to all sewing thread "excluding embroidery". ASTM F1506's thread rule covers the thread that holds the garment together. Both standards then give the same advice for emblems that are not flame resistant: 16 sq in at most for each, 40 sq in for all of them. Benchmark FR, which embroiders the FR shirts it sells, reads them this way. It uses "synthetic non-FR thread" as standard. Reed Manufacturing, another FR garment maker, quotes the same clauses and reaches the same answer.

First, the terms. FR clothing is made from fabric that resists catching fire and puts itself out when the flame is gone. Workers wear it where a flash fire or an electric arc can happen. AR (arc rated) clothing has been tested against an electric arc. NFPA 2112 is the US standard for FR clothing against short flash fires. ASTM F1506 is the US standard for clothing worn by workers exposed to flames and electric arcs. An emblem is anything on the outside that names the company or the person. ASTM lists "logos, name tags, and other heraldry, such as brand names, flag patches and company award insignias". Benchmark and Reed apply the emblem rule to direct embroidery as well as to patches.

Thread makers split FR into two kinds. A fire resistant thread is made of a fiber that will not burn or melt, such as aramid. Aramid is a heat proof synthetic fiber, and Nomex is a brand of it. A flame retardant thread is a normal fiber, such as polyester, with flame protection added. Madeira says its Polyneon FR has it "permanently integrated into the polymer chain".

What the standards say about embroidery

The clause numbers are as Reed quotes them. Benchmark quotes the same wording and dates it. NFPA 2112 first gave emblem advice in its 2018 edition. ASTM F1506 added matching text in its 2019 revision.

NFPA 2112 and ASTM F1506 on thread and emblems, as quoted by Reed Manufacturing and Benchmark FR
ClauseWhat it saysWhat it means for a logo
NFPA 2112, 7.2Sewing thread in FR garments, "excluding embroidery", must be an inherently FR fiber and must not meltEmbroidery thread is left out by name
NFPA 2112, 7.1.4.2Labels and emblems not sold as FR need no heat resistance testA non-FR logo is not tested as a part
NFPA 2112, A.7.1.2.1Non-FR emblems on the outside "should" be five at most, none over 16.0 sq in, all together not over 40 sq inThe size cap and the count
ASTM F1506, 6.1.1Thread used to construct the garment must be an inherently FR fiber and must not meltCovers the seams, not the logo
ASTM F1506, X1.2.5Non-FR logos on the outside "should" be no more than 16 sq in each and 40 sq in in totalThe same cap, with no count

Note the verbs. The thread clauses say "shall". The size advice says "should", and it sits in an annex and an appendix. Reed calls the caps best practices that "are not legally mandated". Every FR seller quoted here still works to them, so treat them as the limit.

OSHA has no embroidery rule of its own. In 2006 an embroiderer asked which OSHA standards apply to embroidering FR clothing. OSHA said its power industry rule requires clothing that "doesn't increase the extent of any injury". It added that the rule "does not specify the construction methods or materials (including the embroidery)". Then it pointed to ASTM F1506.

Why "you must use FR thread" keeps circulating

Some workwear blogs say FR thread is required. Novarlo's guide says embroidery must use "FR-rated thread and backing". It says this "ensures the garment remains compliant with NFPA 70E, ASTM F1506, and NFPA 2112". The clauses above do not say that. NFPA 2112 leaves embroidery thread out by name, and both standards allow non-FR emblems up to a size.

The claim lasts because its starting point is true. Normal embroidery thread is polyester or rayon, and polyester melts (see polyester vs rayon thread). OSHA's letter lists polyester and rayon among fabrics banned for the clothing itself, unless the employer shows how they are worn to remove the hazard. A logo is a small patch of that material on the outside. The standards deal with it by capping the area, not by a thread rule. Tarasafe, an FR clothing brand, agrees that no rule "strictly prohibit[s]" non-FR emblems. It still recommends FR emblems for flash fire, electric arc and molten metal work.

So the blog claim is right in three cases. The design is bigger than the cap. The buyer's spec asks for FR embroidery. Or the garment is certified to a European standard: Tarasafe reads EN ISO 11612 as requiring emblems over 10 cm² (about 1.6 sq in) to pass the ISO 15025 flame spread test.

When you use FR thread, use the whole kit

FR top thread alone is not FR embroidery. Madeira's leaflet says "the choice of bobbin thread plays a vital role". Fire Fighter top thread "should always be paired" with Madeira's 100% aramid bobbin thread. Under Polyneon FR, Polyneon FR "must be used as the bobbin thread", or Fire Fighter bobbin thread. Recheck your bobbin tension when you change bobbin thread. Madeira also sells an aramid backing, so the advice is an FR backing, not the usual cutaway or tearaway. It sells special scissors too, since normal ones "quickly become blunt" on aramid.

Then test the finished piece. Madeira says "only the functionality of the finished workpiece is decisive". It recommends that "the entire product (embroidered textiles) be tested and certified".

The two kinds of FR thread are not interchangeable. In Madeira's standards table, Fire Fighter carries EN ISO 11612 codes A, B and C and the electric arc standard EN 61482-1-2. Polyneon FR carries only EN ISO 11612 codes D and E and EN ISO 14116 index 2. Code A is limited flame spread, B is convective heat and C is radiant heat. D and E are molten aluminum and molten iron splash. So on arc rated clothing, Polyneon FR has no arc mark in that table.

FR embroidery threads by maker

FR embroidery threads from maker data
ThreadFiber and kindSizeNeedleBobbin and notes
Madeira Fire Fighter 40100% aramid with Nomex fibers; fire resistantdtex 130 x 2; 30 colors75/11 to 80/12Madeira aramid bobbin, 5,000 m; tested to EN ISO 15025; arc mark
Madeira Polyneon 40 FR100% polyester filament; flame retardantdtex 135 x 2; 30 colors plus 4 fluorescent60/8 to 75/11Polyneon FR (2,500 m) or Fire Fighter bobbin; no arc mark
Amann N-tech CS EmbroideryNomex meta-aramid, spun; fire resistantNo. 30 (Tex 40), 21 colors; No. 40 (Tex 25)Nm 80 (12) for No. 30; Nm 70 (10) for No. 40Burn tested to EN ISO 15025; industrial laundry to EN ISO 15797
Coats Pyrostar100% spun meta-aramid; fire resistantTex 40, Tex 70, Tex 135Not stated"Recommended for flame resistant embroidery"; up to 371°C

Aramid takes a bigger needle. Madeira gives 75/11 to 80/12 for Fire Fighter, against 60/8 to 75/11 for Polyneon FR. Embroidery needles explains those numbers. The color range is short, 21 to 34 shades per line. Benchmark says the same: "The spectrum of colors available with FR thread is limited." A tex number is grams per 1,000 m, so lower is finer. Coats sells Pyrostar mainly as a sewing thread, which is why its sizes come in tex.

Worked example: a 4 x 4 in left chest logo

Take an FR work shirt sold as meeting NFPA 2112. The customer wants a left chest logo in a 4 x 4 in box, a name on the right chest and a back logo. Left chest placement gives 3 to 3.5 in as the usual width and 4 in as the outside limit. So this logo is already large. Walk it through the caps.

  1. The chest logo. 4 x 4 in = 16 sq in. NFPA says no emblem "greater than" 16 sq in. ASTM says "no more than" 16. So 16 is at the cap, not over it. Benchmark's own limit is exactly this: "16in² (a 4" square)". A round logo 4 in across is smaller: 3.14 x 2 x 2 = about 12.6 sq in.
  2. The name. Suppose it fits a 4 x 1 in box. That is 4 sq in. Total so far: 20 sq in, two emblems.
  3. The maker's emblems. Check the outside of the blank before you count. Benchmark puts two emblems on most of its garments, so it lets customers add three, not five. Suppose this shirt has two maker emblems of 2 sq in each. Total: 24 sq in, four emblems.
  4. What is left. One more emblem under NFPA's count of five, and 16 sq in under the 40 total. A 3.5 x 2 in flag patch (7 sq in) fits.
  5. The back logo. A 10 x 4 in back logo is 40 sq in alone. It breaks the 16 sq in cap for one emblem, so in non-FR thread it is out.
  6. The FR route. Stitch the back in aramid thread, with an aramid bobbin and an FR backing. Then ask the garment maker whether the shirt still meets its certification. Benchmark's other option for large logos is FR printing.

Note what decided it. Thread never came up for the chest logo. The box size did, and so did the emblems already on the shirt.

What this does not cover

This page reads the clauses as Reed and Benchmark quote them. It is not a copy of the standards, which NFPA and ASTM sell. No source here says how to measure an emblem's area, so measuring the full box is the cautious reading. The page does not cover firefighter turnout gear, European rules beyond the test Tarasafe names, or patches fixed with heat seal glue (see heat press settings for patches). The sources set no rule for the backing behind a non-FR logo. Above all, the cap is advice to garment makers. It does not clear one shirt. The garment maker can say whether embroidery affects its certification or warranty. The employer's hazard assessment decides what the worker may wear, and an employer can ask for FR embroidery on every piece. Ask both before a large order. For care, Madeira marks Fire Fighter for 60°C washing and Polyneon FR for 95°C; thread wash and iron temperatures explains those marks.

Frequently asked questions

Does embroidery on FR clothing have to be FR thread?

Not for a normal logo. NFPA 2112 excludes embroidery from its thread rule, and ASTM F1506's thread rule covers construction thread. Both advise that non-FR emblems stay at or under 16 sq in each and 40 sq in in total. Use FR thread when a design is larger or the buyer requires it.

How big can a logo be on an FR shirt?

16 sq in (103 cm²) each, and 40 sq in (258 cm²) for all non-FR emblems together, with NFPA 2112 advising five at most. A 4 x 4 in logo is exactly 16 sq in. Count the maker's own outside labels in the total. See left chest placement for position.

Does embroidery void the FR rating of a garment?

Within the size cap, the standards allow non-FR emblems, so a small logo is not a reason by itself. But the garment maker sets the terms of its own certification and warranty. Ask the maker before you embroider a large order, and follow the employer's hazard assessment.

Is Nomex thread the same as FR thread?

Nomex is a brand of meta-aramid fiber, a fire resistant fiber. Madeira Fire Fighter, Amann N-tech CS and Coats Pyrostar are aramid. Madeira's Polyneon FR is a different kind: flame retardant polyester, with no arc mark in Madeira's table.

Can I use regular bobbin thread with FR embroidery thread?

Not if the embroidery is meant to be FR. Madeira says Fire Fighter top thread should always be paired with its aramid bobbin thread, and that Polyneon FR must be used as the bobbin under Polyneon FR. The backing should be FR as well. See bobbin tension when you change bobbin thread.

Sources and further reading

Found something wrong or out of date? Tell us and we will fix it.